My Opinion
Reviewed in the United States on March 2, 2025
Wore them while in the Colorado mountains. They are of good quality, comfortable because I wore them all day. They were not heavy and fit true to size. At some points my feet dis get cold but were not freezing and I was able to walk comfortably across the snow and ice.
Diana Wilson
Reviewed in the United States on March 1, 2025
I was looking for a boot that was higher, waterproof, comfortable and cute. I found it with these they're fantastic. My 2 sisters and me were shoveling for 3 hours.Their feet were wet and cold and mine were warm and dry. :) I actually sent the link to one sister and two friends they bought a pair! And, for Columbia brand; the price was right
M F
Reviewed in the United States on February 17, 2025
Great black boots that look nice and keep your feet dry and warm. Was pleased with the fit. They are very comfortable. Good tread. They are not heavy boots, so they are easy to wear. I would definitely purchase these again or recommend. Good price for the excellent quality, look, and comfort.
Adeline
Reviewed in the United States on February 16, 2025
Warm, waterproof, comfortable, and cute. The boots aren't too heavy or bulky but give enough protection from the elements. They have really good traction in the snow, much less slippery on ice compared to other shoes. The fit is perfect (usually wear US womens 11, bought US women's 11) and the sole is firm but not so firm that it's uncomfortable; its still bouncy and forms to the shape of your foot. I bought these boots for my 10-15 minute walk into work and they're perfect. Still easy to get on and off with the laces.
Lexi
Reviewed in the United States on January 21, 2025
After tons of deliberating, I ordered these and "Kamik Women's Momentum 3 Snow Boot" and tried them both on. They're extremely similar but I kept these. Here are the differences I noticed:- The Columbias had a slightly more stylish feel to them.- They both had amazing tread and were the same height and style.- The Kamiks had more "puff" to them and felt more comfortable right away without thick socks as extra cushion.- The Kamiks had more of a hardcore winter sport feel to them.My review of these Columbia boots:I live in northern Ohio, where there are a few months of the year where there's snow on the ground and temperatures hover around 25 Fahrenheit. These boots are perfect for wearing on the snowy/icy days.They have decent tread on the ice, which I especially notice whenever I switch to a different pair of shoes and am slipping all over. They're warm: no longer are my toes freezing after shoveling snow or waiting for the car to warm up.I recently tested them on a very slow walk that lasted 45 minutes at 6°F, at times through 10" of snow. My feet stayed perfectly warm.I'll say that they are roomy and don't feel as comfortable if you're not wearing thick socks. I don't think sizing up/down would change this.
Kalea blanke
Reviewed in the United States on January 20, 2025
I like everything about these boots. My feet stay dry and warm, they're comfortable, they're cute, and they're true to size (I'm a 12 women)! The only thing I can say that I didn't like were the insoles. They were very hard, so I replaced them with some dr.sholls gel inserts. Great investment 👌
Ciclochick
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on January 16, 2025
I had to replace my Sorel snow boots as they were too small. I was after a mid-calf-height, waterproof, fluffy boot and these tick all the boxes. Whilst I'm a size 5, I sized up to a 6 to enable thick socks. They are nice and wide, super comfy, really warm and look great. Can highly recommend.
Bug Lady
Reviewed in the United States on January 15, 2025
I recently purchased the Columbia Women's Ice Maiden II boots in Black/Columbia Grey, and while they have some good features, I was a bit disappointed overall.Pros:- The style is great! The boots look exactly like the picture and are stylish enough to wear both for outdoor activities and casual outings.- The insulation seems good, and they feel warm enough for colder weather.- The traction on the soles is solid, and I’m sure they’ll perform well on snowy or slippery surfaces.Cons:Fit: These boots run big. I usually wear a size 7, but I ended up returning them as they felt way too roomy. I recommend sizing down if you're in between sizes or if you prefer a snugger fit.Stiffness: The boots are much stiffer than I anticipated. The leather and synthetic materials feel quite rigid, especially around the ankle area. It made walking a bit uncomfortable at first, and I’m sure they would break in over time.Comfort: The insole is okay, but not as plush as I expected.Overall, while the boots are durable and warm, the fit and stiffness are a letdown for me. I do think they’d work better for someone with wider feet or someone who doesn't mind a bit of stiffness during the break-in period.
poussicat03
Reviewed in France on December 18, 2024
Achetez pour aller en Finlande et très bien, étanche et pieds bien au sec et au chaud même en temps de neige et de pluie. Comme des chaussons.
Crhurley
Reviewed in the United States on December 16, 2024
Im going on a Christmas vacation to a very cold and snowy destination. I needed a pair of winter snow boots that could keep my feet warm and dry, along with maintaining my art support and being comfortable while wearing them throughout the day. I found these boots and happened to catch them when they were on sale, so I went ahead and took the offer. I sure am glad I did because these boots meet all of my needs that I listed above and more. I typically wear a size 9 in boots. I ordered a size 10. I do have wiggle room but I also will be wearing very thick socks, so I do recommend sizing up. I tested these boots in the rain and puddles. They held up to the weather resistance that they claim. I had absolutely no wetness whatsoever on my socks or pants. They aren't the most comfortable pair of boots I ever have worn, but they are definitely nowhere near the worst. I would say that the comfortability of the boot on a scale from 0 - 10, I would give these boots a solid 8. And I take my shoe game very seriously, so for me to say that they're actually really cute is a very big compliment. I would say eighty five percent of the winter snow boots that are sold on amazon ( no offense to any sellers whatsoever) are mid at best... Theres some really cute ones out there that fit, are resistant to water/wind/weather, ect... but they are over $200. If you're looking for a cute, nice fitting, pretty comfortable ( enough to get you through the day and still be able to walk on your feet), durable and tough, slip resistant, and easy on the bank them you should give these boots a try. All you have to do is order them in your size and the color that you like. And when they get to you, try them on, walk around a little bit, test them out, and see what you think ;)
Stan Zee
Reviewed in Canada on December 1, 2020
Properly Fit , warm and stylish!
Motorhead
Reviewed in Canada on November 23, 2020
well made and warm
Edith P.
Reviewed in Mexico on June 20, 2019
Super calientita y pesan algo